Don't assume that past success is a predictor of future success.
As Chief Executive Officer (CEO), an executive will face a whole new set of personalities and conditions.
- Investigate a candidate's integrity and interpersonal skills as part of a thorough background check. Conduct extensive and confidential discussions with former associates.
- In interviews, ask candidates how they have handled setbacks and challenges in the past, as well as personal interactions.
- In examining the course of a candidate's promotions, pay close attention to how the candidate reacted when given new responsibilities that significantly increased his or her power.
- Determine how much of an executive's career success has been based on favorable economic and industry conditions and the support of colleagues, and how much has been based on the executive's individual efforts. Pay close attention to how candidates performed when industry conditions were bad. Note: bad industry conditions are an excellent time to build market share.
- Each finalist for the CEO position should be provided with a detailed job preview.
- Be clear about ethics. Provide as much information as possible to finalists about how the board expects shareholders, employees, customers and other stakeholders to be treated.
- Offer the new CEO a reasonable compensation package. Once the CEO has demonstrated a high level of competency and integrity, the compensation package can be improved.
It's easy to spot a bad CEO once the damage is done but spotting flaws before hiring can reduce the likelihood of hiring a dysfunctional leader.
Source: The Wall Street Journal, December 1, 2007